“AI and animal welfare: am I missing something?” by SiobhanBall

About this episode

SiobhanBall discusses the intersection of AI and animal welfare, questioning the indifference towards animal welfare in AI decision-making.

Animal welfare is what brought me to EA. I spent several years working for animal advocacy organisations, and the EA ideals to do with rigorous thinking about where effort makes the biggest difference was something I believed in fully. This post is me thinking aloud, not staking a firm position. I'd genuinely welcome pushback from people who know this space better than I do. The framing of the problem is a bit odd to me The AI x animals argument, as I understand it: AI systems are making decisions that affect how we use animals. Those systems don't adequately represent animal welfare. If we can get welfare into the benchmarks/constitutions of AI labs, we can shift outcomes for animals at huge scale before they get locked in. Okay. But nobody is 'ignoring' animal welfare; they're just indifferent. AI systems are being built to do exactly what they were designed to do, which is to faithfully execute human preferences. And those are, in aggregate, to eat cheap meat, conduct research on living organisms when it's convenient, and prioritise cost and efficiency in agricultural supply chains. AI is reflecting the values of the humans. I don't think [...] --- First published: April 25th…

People in this episode

Guest: SiobhanBall

Topics covered

• AI
• animal welfare
• effective altruism
• decision making
• human preferences
• agriculture

Keywords

• animal advocacy
• AI systems
• human values
• cost efficiency
• agricultural supply chains
• welfare benchmarks

More episodes of EA Forum Podcast (All audio)

• [Linkpost] “The Quest To Find The Next Big Communicators In AI Safety” by Akshyae Singh · June 12, 2026 · 15 min
• [Linkpost] “Scale Scale Scale, Govt. Govt. Govt: 3 concerns” by NickLaing · June 12, 2026 · 10 min
• “Building Ideas-First EA” by Mjreard · June 11, 2026 · 7 min
• “Call for mentors: Sentient Futures Project Incubator” by Sentient Futures, Jay Luong, Constance Li, Sam Chapman, Brody McManus · June 11, 2026 · 2 min
• [Linkpost] “Are top existential risk estimates 50,000 times too high? An optimizer’s curse model and analysis” by titotal · June 11, 2026 · 1h 2m
• “Incumbents Might Be Replaced During AI Takeoff, Including in Animal Agriculture” by Hazo · June 11, 2026 · 13 min