The Don Juan of Nauvoo

About this episode

This episode explores provocative historical accounts of Joseph Smith's behavior in Nauvoo as recounted by his contemporaries.

In this episode, we step into one of the most provocative and uncomfortable chapters ever written about Joseph Smith — “The Don Juan of Nauvoo,” from Dr. W. Wyl’s 1886 exposé. These are not modern critics looking backward with hindsight. These are men and women living in Utah in the late 1800s — people who lived through Nauvoo, who knew Joseph personally, who saw the culture firsthand, and who were willing to share their memories of Joseph’s behavior with women. Their recollections paint a portrait very different from the sanitized image often presented today. We will read their words directly. Their observations. Their accusations. Their recollections of Joseph’s charisma, his influence, and his interactions with women in Nauvoo. This episode isn’t about speculation. It’s about historical memory — and how Joseph Smith’s contemporaries understood him. You’ll hear: How Joseph was perceived by those who lived in Nauvoo The reputation he carried among insiders What Utah Saints privately said decades later Why these accounts were preserved and published And how charisma, authority, and attraction intersected in Nauvoo Whether you see Joseph Smith as prophet, fraud, or something in…

People in this episode

Host: Mormon Discussion Inc

Topics covered

• Joseph Smith
• Nauvoo
• historical memory
• contemporary accounts
• charisma and authority
• faith transition

Keywords

• Joseph Smith
• Nauvoo
• historical accounts
• W. Wyl
• faith transition
• charisma
• authority
• spiritual trauma

More episodes of Mormonism Live! – Radio Free Mormon

• The Forensic Autopsy of Mormon Apologetics · June 11, 2026 · 2h 18m
• LDS Church Membership Tanks! · June 4, 2026 · 2h 32m
• Podcaster Meggan Hayes (Generally Unquotable) Joins the Show! · May 21, 2026 · 2h 12m
• Moroni As A Treasure Guardian · May 14, 2026 · 2h 58m
• The Hidden Cost of Mormon Belief: Conditioned From Childhood · May 13, 2026 · 1h 54m
• Another Mormon Bites The Dust! · May 7, 2026 · 2h 33m