Pageau: The Monsters and the Cynics

About this episode

Fr. Andrew discusses with Jonathan Pageau the significance of monsters in the context of the Christian story and heroism, referencing Tolkien's insights on Beowulf.

In his 1936 lecture "Beowulf: The Monsters and the Critics," J. R. R. Tolkien refuted the prevailing Beowulf scholarship of his day, which disdained the poem for its focus on monsters. He had this to say about the Old English epic: “I would suggest, then, that the monsters are not an inexplicable blunder of taste; they are essential, fundamentally allied to the underlying ideas of the poem, which give it its lofty tone and high seriousness.” Fr. Andrew sits down with ‪Jonathan Pageau‬ in his Montreal home to discuss whether and how the monsters make sense of our world today, what they have to do with the Christian story, as well as the place of the hero in facing the monsters.

People in this episode

Host: Fr. Andrew Stephen Damick

Guest: Jonathan Pageau

Topics covered

• monsters
• Christian story
• heroism
• Beowulf
• Tolkien
• cynicism

Keywords

• monsters
• Christianity
• Beowulf
• Tolkien
• hero
• cynicism
• epic poetry

Mentioned in this episode

Books & works: Beowulf

More episodes of Orthodox Engagement

• Orthodox Christianity: Root and Branch (w/ Dr. David Ford) · March 24, 2026
• NEW FILM: "Moses the Black" (w/ Yelena Popovic) · January 15, 2026
• Re-enchantment in Church Art and Architecture (w/ Fr. Lucas Christensen) · December 16, 2025
• Orthodox Christianity, Art, and Sacred Space in Norway - Fr. Theodor & Mat. Hanne Svane · December 4, 2025
• American Orthodoxy in 2040 · October 14, 2025
• Tikhon of Moscow: American, Russian & Lithuanian Saint - Scott Kenworthy · September 15, 2025