
River City Mystery - Investigating mysteries in southern Indiana, southern Illinois, and western Kentucky
by Matt Deig
Is this your podcast?Insights from recent episode analysis
Audience Interest
Podcast Focus
Publishing Consistency
Platform Reach
Insights are generated by CastFox AI using publicly available data, episode content, and proprietary models.
Most discussed topics
Brands & references
Est. Listeners
Insufficient chart data. Estimates will improve as the show charts.
- Per-Episode Audience
Est. listeners per new episode within ~30 days
N/A🎙 Weekly cadence·22 episodes·Last published 5mo ago - Monthly Reach
Unique listeners across all episodes (30 days)
N/A - Active Followers
Loyal subscribers who consistently listen
N/A
Market Insights
Platform Distribution
Reach across major podcast platforms, updated hourly
Total Followers
—
Total Plays
—
Total Reviews
—
* Data sourced directly from platform APIs and aggregated hourly across all major podcast directories.
On the show
From 10 epsHost
Recent guests
Recent episodes
The Timber Lake Murder: Who Killed Arthur Denton?
Jan 9, 2026
16m 55s
The Burrows Cave Mystery
Dec 8, 2025
22m 02s
Wildman Joe
Apr 21, 2025
14m 15s
Who Killed Jean Cook?
Feb 5, 2025
26m 46s
Interview with a Forest Witch
Jan 18, 2025
1h 14m 53s
Social Links & Contact
Official channels & resources
Official Website
Login
RSS Feed
Login
| Date | Episode | Topics | Guests | Brands | Places | Keywords | Sponsor | Length | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1/9/26 | ![]() The Timber Lake Murder: Who Killed Arthur Denton?✨ | murder investigationtrue crime+3 | — | — | Posey County, IndianaMiddle Mount Vernon Road | Timber Lake murderArthur Denton+5 | — | 16m 55s | |
| 12/8/25 | ![]() The Burrows Cave Mystery✨ | Burrows Cavearchaeology+4 | — | — | Olney, Illinois | Burrows CaveRussell E. Burrows+4 | — | 22m 02s | |
| 4/21/25 | ![]() Wildman Joe✨ | true crimehistory+4 | — | — | EvansvilleNorth Carolina | Wildman JoeJoe Rettig+6 | — | 14m 15s | |
| 2/5/25 | ![]() Who Killed Jean Cook?✨ | unsolved murdertrue crime+3 | Andy HintonFred Cook | Vanderburgh County Sheriff's Department | Evansville, Indiana | Jean Cookmurder+3 | — | 26m 46s | |
| 1/18/25 | ![]() Interview with a Forest Witch✨ | witchcraftanimism+5 | Crystal Folz | Three Corners Pagan CircleSouthern Indiana Paranormal Investigators | EvansvilleKentucky+2 | witchcraftanimism+5 | — | 1h 14m 53s | |
| 12/16/24 | ![]() Who Killed Elizabeth?✨ | unsolved murdertrue crime+3 | Savannah | — | Evansville, Indiana | Elizabeth Bannistermurder+5 | — | 55m 24s | |
| 3/26/24 | ![]() Where is Zac? Interview with his best friend, Chris✨ | missing persontrue crime+3 | Chris | 14 WFIE NEWS | Warrick CountyLynnville+2 | Zac Carymissing person+7 | — | 42m 23s | |
| 3/7/24 | ![]() Where is Zac?✨ | disappearancefamily interviews+3 | GinaCecilia | — | LynnvilleEvansville+1 | Zac Careymissing person+3 | — | 32m 12s | |
| 10/7/23 | ![]() Bigfoot Encounters in the Hoosier National Forest✨ | BigfootSasquatch+5 | Angela | Bigfoot Field Researchers Organization | Hoosier National ForestSouthern Indiana+1 | BigfootSasquatch+6 | — | 38m 12s | |
| 8/15/23 | ![]() The Murder of Troy DeWayne Smith✨ | murder investigationtrue crime+4 | — | — | Evansville, Indiana | Troy DeWayne Smithmurder+6 | — | 15m 40s | |
Want analysis for the episodes below?Free for Pro Submit a request, we'll have your selected episodes analyzed within an hour. Free, at no cost to you, for Pro users. | |||||||||
| 8/1/23 | ![]() Buried Treasure in the Tri-State? | A hoard of 700 civil war-era gold coins was found buried at an undisclosed Kentucky cornfield in July, 2023. Was this a unique case, or is it possible that buried treasures may be found all over the tri-state area? | 12m 28s | ||||||
| 6/29/23 | ![]() Where is Andi? | This episode focuses on the ongoing search for 24-year-old Andi Wagner, who was last seen in Evansville, Indiana, on August 6, 2022. Here's a summary of the key information discussed: The Search Efforts: The episode highlights the active involvement of Andi's family and friends in the search, including their efforts on the "Where is Andi?" Facebook page. [02:52] Community Collaboration: Learn about the collaboration between Rick White, the former Emergency Management Director in Union County, Kentucky, and YouTubers Trey and Ronnie, who organized searches in local waterways. [04:21] Family Insights: Hear a clip from an interview with Andi's cousin, Frankie Lee, who discusses the unusual circumstances surrounding Andi's disappearance and mentions a neighbor's involvement with ring camera footage. [06:02] Search Updates and Theories: The host interviews Rick White about the planned search efforts and his perspectives on the case, including potential reasons for the lack of progress in the investigation. [18:21] Call for Information: The episode concludes with a direct appeal to anyone who may have information about Andi's whereabouts to contact the Evansville Police Department at 812-436-7979. [32:44] Show Notes: https://www.rivercitymystery.com/11 Join the River City Mystery Discord channel to meet others from the tri-state area who are into true crime and the paranormal. https://www.rivercitymystery.com/discord Where is Andi - Facebook Group Andi's GoFundMe page ***** In this episode: Interview with Rick White, former Emergency Management Director in Union County, Kentucky. Rick's TikTok: Front Porch America JuJu's Rabbit Hole - Interview with Franky Lee (Andi's cousin) Narked Divers Brother's Underwater Recovery WEVV-44 - Family searching for missing woman Andi Wagner | 33m 39s | ||||||
| 3/10/23 | ![]() Phantom Train | This episode explores the intriguing phenomenon of phantom trains, sharing eerie accounts and legends of trains heard or even seen when no physical train is present. Here's a summary of the occurrences discussed: Police Hear a Ghost Train: The episode begins with a news story about two police officers in Swadlincote, England, who reported hearing a phantom train on a railway line that no longer exists. [01:12] Barbie's Revival Experience: Matt's sister, Barbie Deig, recounts her own unsettling experience from the early 1990s at a revival where she and many others distinctly heard a train despite no train being visible. [03:41] Famous Phantom Train Legends: Matt discusses well-known instances of phantom trains throughout history, including the spectral sightings of Abraham Lincoln's funeral train. [08:15] Share Your Stories: The host encourages listeners who have had similar experiences with phantom trains or who attended the mentioned revival to share their stories on the podcast's Discord server. [08:46] Show Notes: https://www.rivercitymystery.com/10 Join the River City Mystery Discord channel to meet others from the tri-state area who are into true crime and the paranormal. https://www.rivercitymystery.com/discord https://www.staffordshire-live.co.uk/news/local-news/terrifying-ghost-train-reported-swadlincote-8218578 https://www.facebook.com/SwadlincoteSNT/posts/pfbid02atTUUMR1XQ6X3fkEdawy7UCADgWDryLRcHgKDet1nDKrWGSzyare8fQnBukYN7PCl https://www.coasttocoastam.com/article/british-cops-report-hearing-phantom-train/ | 9m 17s | ||||||
| 1/7/23 | ![]() The Kelly-Hopkinsville ”Little Green Men” Encounter | This episode dives into the bizarre and enduring mystery of the Kelly-Hopkinsville "Little Green Men" Encounter, a case often cited as a significant Close Encounter of the Third Kind. Here's a breakdown of the key details discussed: Geraldine Sutton Stith's Account: The episode features an interview with Geraldine Sutton Stith, the daughter of Elmer Lucky Sutton, one of the eleven individuals who claimed to have been terrorized by strange creatures on their rural Kentucky farm in the summer of 1955. [01:01] The Initial Sightings: Learn about the first sighting by Billy Ray Taylor, who reported seeing an unusual oval, silver object with rainbow colors in the sky. [02:16] Later that evening, both Billy Ray and Lucky Sutton encountered the first of the creatures, described as having large ears, glowing eyes, and arms that extended to the ground. [05:40] The Farm Under Siege: Hear the incredible story of how the family reacted to the appearance of multiple creatures, including their attempts to shoot the beings, which seemed to have no effect. [08:46] Seeking Help in Hopkinsville: Understand the family's fear and their decision to seek assistance from the authorities in Hopkinsville. [09:01] The Official Response: The episode details the investigation by local police and others, who arrived at the farm but found no concrete evidence of the creatures. [09:46] The Aftermath for the Sutton Family: Learn about the profound impact of the encounter on the Sutton family, leading them to sell their farm within two weeks due to fear. [14:24] The episode also notes that the case was never officially investigated by any higher authorities. [17:21] Challenging Explanations: While some have proposed alternative explanations for the sightings, such as owls, cats, or monkeys, the speaker, Geraldine Sutton Stith, firmly believes it was an encounter with extraterrestrial beings. [25:42] Addressing Misconceptions: The episode clarifies a common misconception about the case, stating that alcohol was not a factor during the night of the alleged encounter. [35:56] Show Notes: https://www.rivercitymystery.com/9 Join the River City Mystery Discord channel to meet others from the tri-state area who are into true crime and the paranormal. https://www.rivercitymystery.com/discord Check out Geraldine's Etsy page for her books and merch: https://www.etsy.com/shop/aliensandgoblins Information on Geraldine's appearance on UFO Witness: https://www.imdb.com/title/tt13889478/ | 44m 13s | ||||||
| 12/21/22 | ![]() Interview with Joni Mayhan | This episode features an interview with author, medium, and paranormal investigator Joni Mayhan, who shares her experiences and knowledge of the paranormal, with a particular focus on the historically rich town of New Harmony, Indiana. Here's a breakdown of the fascinating topics covered: Introduction to Joni Mayhan: Learn about Joni's background as an author of books on haunted locations in Posey County and New Harmony, Indiana, and her belief in the importance of history in understanding paranormal activity. [01:02], [01:09] The Unique Energy of New Harmony: Discover why New Harmony is considered a unique location for paranormal phenomena, possibly due to its history of utopian societies and potential geological factors. [02:38] Acceptance in a Small Town: Hear about Joni's experience as an openly practicing medium and paranormal investigator in a small, religious community. [05:14] Haunted Ghost Walks: Learn about the popularity of Joni's ghost walks in New Harmony and their contribution to the town's tourism. [06:41] First Encounter at the Arbor House: Joni recounts her initial paranormal experience in New Harmony at the Arbor House, where she encountered the spirit of an older woman. [08:32] Upcoming Public Investigation: Find out about an upcoming public paranormal investigation at the historic Arbor House. [08:25] Clairaudience Explained: Understand Joni's ability to perceive paranormal activity through hearing specific tones. [09:55], [13:12] Being a "Ghost Magnet": Joni describes herself as someone who attracts paranormal activity and the importance of having a mentor for protection. [14:24] Goals of Paranormal Investigations: Learn about Joni's objectives during investigations, which include assisting residents and helping spirits transition. [16:18] Activities of Ghosts: Explore the possibilities of what ghosts might do in their afterlife. [17:57] New Harmony as a "Thin Place": The episode discusses the concept of New Harmony being a location where the veil between the living and the dead is thin. [19:05] Unusual Hauntings: Hear about the strange case of a newly built Dollar General store that is reportedly haunted. [19:48] Likely Haunted Locations: Joni shares insights into the types of places, such as nursing homes and hospitals, that are often associated with hauntings. [24:14] Paranormal Investigation Equipment: The episode mentions the tools commonly used in paranormal investigations, including Spirit Boxes and SLS cameras. [25:51] A Skeptical Investigator: Discover that Joni identifies as a skeptic who values evidence and approaches paranormal phenomena with caution. [27:45] Animal Sensitivity to Ghosts: Learn about the belief that animals, especially cats, can detect the presence of ghosts. [31:37] Ghostly Interactions: The varying abilities of ghosts to interact physically with their surroundings are discussed. [33:10] Earthbound Spirits and Suicide: Joni shares her experiences with spirits of individuals who died by suicide often remaining Earthbound and her ability to assist them in crossing over. [34:07] Communicating with Ghosts: Hear about Joni's methods of communicating with ghosts, sometimes through automatic writing. [35:14] The Afterlife Mystery: The difficulty in obtaining information about the afterlife from Earthbound spirits is mentioned. [37:03] Validating Ghostly Presence: Learn about the techniques used to validate the presence of ghosts during paranormal investigations. [37:23] Show Notes: https://www.rivercitymystery.com/8 Join the River City Mystery Discord channel to meet others from the tri-state area who are into true crime and the paranormal. https://www.rivercitymystery.com/discord Haunted New Harmony | Where History and Hauntings Collide (jonimayhan.com) Joni Mayhan (@jonimayhan933) TikTok | Watch Joni Mayhan's Newest TikTok Videos Amazon.com: Joni Mayhan: books, biography, latest update | 45m 12s | ||||||
| 12/11/22 | ![]() The Murder of Doris McDonough | This episode delves into the tragic and unsolved murder of 36-year-old Doris McDonough, a wife and mother who was brutally killed in her Evansville, Indiana, home on October 3, 1968. Here's a summary of the key details discussed in the episode: The Brutal Crime Scene: Learn about the horrific discovery of Doris' body in her kitchen, detailing the severe head, face, neck, and back trauma she sustained from being beaten with a heavy, blunt object. [00:43], [00:48] Initial Investigation Details: Understand the initial confusion of investigators who first suspected a shooting, only to discover through the autopsy that Doris was beaten to death. The presence of a struggle and towels wrapped around her head wounds are also highlighted. [03:34] The Missing Hammer: The episode points out the significant detail of a missing claw hammer from the McDonough residence, which investigators theorized could have been the murder weapon. [04:30] Husband's Account and Timeline: In this episode, we meticulously examine the detailed timeline provided by Doris' husband, William McDonough, to the Evansville Press just eight days after the murder, outlining his activities on the day of the crime. [08:04] Inconsistencies and Suspicious Elements: Matt critically analyzes William's timeline, drawing attention to certain inconsistencies and odd explanations, such as the timing of his visits and the reason given for leaving the back door unlocked. [13:55] A Case Gone Cold: Despite the initial investigation and scrutiny of the evidence, the episode underscores the fact that no one was ever charged in Doris McDonough's murder, and the case remains unsolved to this day. [07:13] Research Sources: The host acknowledges and credits "The Bones of Autumn" from Reddit and her book, "Unsolved Indiana Murder Mysteries, Bizarre Deaths and Unexplained Disappearances," as key sources for the information presented in the episode. [07:22] Show Notes: https://www.rivercitymystery.com/7 Join the River City Mystery Discord channel to meet others from the tri-state area who are into true crime and the paranormal. https://www.rivercitymystery.com/discord Unsolved Indiana: Murder Mysteries, Bizarre Deaths, & Unexplained Disappearances by Autumn Bones The Bones of Autumn – Reddit | 22m 16s | ||||||
| 9/4/22 | ![]() Interview with Joe Weigant | This episode features an interview with Joe Weigant, the founder of Evansville Paranormal Investigations and Consulting (EPIC) and a retired detective with the Evansville Police Department. Joe shares his unique perspective on paranormal investigations, blending his law enforcement background with his abilities as a psychic and spirit communicator. Here are the key topics discussed in the episode: Introduction to Joe Weigant: Learn about Joe's background as a retired detective and his current work as a psychic and spirit communicator. He also owns Tri-State Holistic Wellness, where he utilizes energy work for holistic healing. [01:18] The Philosophy of EPIC: Discover EPIC's approach to paranormal investigations, which focuses on resolving paranormal issues by communicating with and helping spirits cross over, rather than solely collecting evidence. [02:27] Reasons for Spirits Remaining Earthbound: Joe explains the various reasons why spirits might linger in the earthly realm, including fear of judgment, strong attachments, or a lack of awareness of their passing. [09:54] Methods of Spirit Communication: Understand the challenges spirits face when trying to communicate and the common forms of communication, such as Electronic Voice Phenomena (EVPs) and shadowy figures. [17:41] Distinguishing Spirits from "Demons": Joe clarifies the difference between typical spirits and what are often referred to as "demons," describing the latter as entities from other dimensions that feed on emotional energy, particularly fear. [27:52] Case Study: Dog-like Creatures and a Powerful Entity: Hear a compelling account of a specific paranormal case where Joe encountered unusual dog-like creatures and a powerful entity that required intervention from Archangel Michael. [37:48] Case Study: Helping Murdered Native American Spirits: Joe recounts his experience helping a group of Native American spirits who were murdered and unable to move on. [45:38] The Practice of Smudging: Learn about the ancient practice of smudging, which involves burning specific elements to clear negative energy, and the importance of the practitioner's intention. [01:04:16] Understanding the Prayer Position: Joe explains the significance of the prayer position in the context of aromatherapy and various cultural practices. [01:21:50] Joe's Experience on Paranormal 911: Get insights into Joe's appearance on the Travel Channel show Paranormal 911, including his perspective on the differences between his actual experiences and how they were portrayed on television. [01:23:08] Show Notes: https://www.rivercitymystery.com/6 Join the River City Mystery Discord channel to meet others from the tri-state area who are into true crime and the paranormal. https://www.rivercitymystery.com/discord https://www.tristateholisticwellness.com/ https://www.facebook.com/paranormalpeace/# | 1h 27m 30s | ||||||
| 8/6/22 | ![]() The Murder of Blake Crews | Blake Crews, 20, was excited to start a business teaching drums. He spent much of his last day alive trying to print business cards for the new business. Blake never had the chance to live out his dream, though; he died after he was shot multiple times in the face while staying at a friend’s house in Henderson, Kentucky in January, 2015. The case remains unsolved to this day. | 43m 18s | ||||||
| 5/1/22 | ![]() The Odon Fire Poltergeist | During the summer of 1940, a home just outside of Odon, Indiana, caught fire 28 times in a single day. Witnessed by many, the cause of the fires remains a mystery to this very day. | 18m 20s | ||||||
| 12/4/21 | ![]() The Disappearance of Theresa Rideout | Theresa Rideout, 36, disappeared along with her dog, River, on September 2, 1994. Her boyfriend, Jack Barnett, checked into a motel and killed himself just over a week later. Was Jack responsible for her disappearance? Investigators never found her body or evidence of a crime scene. What happened to Theresa Rideout? | 23m 38s | ||||||
| 8/23/21 | ![]() Garvin Lake Creature | My wife and I had an encounter with something unusual while taking a walk around Garvin Lake in Evansville on the evening of Saturday, August 21, 2021. | 11m 08s | ||||||
| 5/28/21 | ![]() Four Seasons | Discover why a preacher was called to help deal with a disturbing situation at the Four Seasons Motel in Mount Vernon, Indiana. | 18m 25s | ||||||
Showing 22 of 22
Pitch Fit is a Pro feature
See how bookable this show is for guests, which brands already advertise, the per-episode ad value, and the best-fit guest and sponsor profile. The numbers are blurred on the free plan.
How readily this show books outside guests like you.
How proven this show is for host-read sponsorships.
For Guests
ProFor Advertisers
ProUpgrade to Pro to unlock guest cadence, sponsor categories, fit scores, and per-episode ad value for this show.






















