Golf Rules We'd Keep, Kill, and Rewrite

About this episode

The episode discusses potential changes to golf rules and their implications on fairness, skill, and tradition in the game.

What should never change about golf? And what should have been changed years ago? With the U.S. Open at Shinnecock Hills around the corner, Matt and the Professor crack open the Rules of Golf and start drafting their own version of the game. From lost-ball penalties and green-reading books to arm-lock putters, divots, and pace of play, they each pick the rule changes they love, the ones they question, the ones they'd like to see, and the ones they hope survive forever. What starts as a conversation about golf's rulebook quickly becomes something bigger: a debate about fairness, skill, technology, tradition, and what the game is actually trying to reward. What the conversation dives into: Why the 2019 Rules modernization may have been one of the most important pace-of-play initiatives in modern golf The forgotten experiments with out-of-bounds penalties, including eras when stroke-and-distance didn't exist Whether arm-lock putters, oversized grips, and modern equipment have drifted too far from the spirit of the game The case for enforcing pace of play as a competitive skill, not just a courtesy Why "play it as it lies" remains one of golf's most important ideas, even when your…

People in this episode

Host: Matt

Guest: the Professor

Topics covered

• golf rules
• fairness in golf
• technology in golf
• pace of play
• tradition in golf
• rule changes

Keywords

• golf rules
• U.S. Open
• pace of play
• arm-lock putters
• divots
• stroke-and-distance
• 2019 Rules modernization

Mentioned in this episode

Organizations: NewClub Golf Society

Books & works: 1744 Rules of Golf

Places: U.S. Open, Shinnecock Hills

More episodes of The Bag Drop: Untold Stories in Golf

• Golf, Identity, and Starting Over · May 11, 2026 · 1h 10m
• A Club Without a Course, A Community With Purpose · May 4, 2026 · 1h 4m
• The Ghost Name in Golf Course Architecture · April 28, 2026 · 1h 27m
• Where Golf Still Feels Like Golf: North Berwick to Royal Melbourne · April 20, 2026 · 1h 31m
• The Re-Making of the Masters? · April 10, 2026 · 59 min
• Hooper Golf Course: Community, Stewardship, and the Heart of 9-Hole Golf · April 6, 2026 · 1h 2m