The Bar That Inspired Piano Man

About this episode

Shane Rosenthal revisits his investigation into the bar that inspired Billy Joel's 'Piano Man' after a new HBO documentary.

After watching a new HBO documentary on the life of Billy Joel, Shane decided to reopen his investigation of the bar that inspired Piano Man. The question he posed on the pilot episode was whether his dad had visited the famous bar back in 1973, and whether he might even be one of the characters mentioned in the song. This program features Shane’s original exploration, along with selections from interviews he’s recorded since that time. In the final segment, he engages with individuals involved in this new documentary, which takes his investigation to a whole new level. SHOW NOTES Articles Is My Dad One of the Characters in Piano Man ? Shane Rosenthal The Executive Room According to Bob Egan , Pop Spots Related Episodes The Executive Room: New Evidence , #55 with John Gibson Evidential Reasoning , #56 with Craig Parton Dealing with Discrepancies , #57 with J. Warner Wallace Year-End Special , #65 with Liam Cooper The Pilot Episode , #01 (Shane’s original investigation) Video And So It Goes , HBO documentary series on the life of Billy Joel And So It Goes (Trailer ) A Recent Note from a Paid Subscriber: “I’m a listener from the UK, and have listened to just about all of your…

People in this episode

Host: Shane Rosenthal

Guests: John Gibson, Craig Parton, J. Warner Wallace, Liam Cooper

Topics covered

• Billy Joel
• Piano Man
• HBO documentary
• investigation
• music history
• personal stories

Keywords

• Billy Joel
• Piano Man
• HBO
• investigation
• music
• documentary
• characters
• 1973

Mentioned in this episode

Organizations: HBO

Books & works: Piano Man, And So It Goes, And So It Goes (Trailer)

More episodes of The Humble Skeptic

• The Cambridge Declaration · April 21, 2026 · 1h 19m
• Lazarus · April 3, 2026 · 33 min
• The Annunciation & Incarnation · December 22, 2025 · 26 min
• A Forensic Approach to the Gospels · October 15, 2025 · 44 min
• Luke, Theophilus & Joanna · September 24, 2025 · 38 min
• Who Is Theophilus? · September 5, 2025 · 37 min