Coach vs Pro Player: Who Develops Players Better?

Coach vs Pro Player: Who Develops Players Better?

From Train 2.0 Show with Jason Yee by Jason Yee - Train 2.0

January 3, 2026 · 12 min

About this episode

This episode explores the debate on whether professional coaches or players are better at developing hockey talent.

In this episode of The Train 2.0 Show, Coach Kevin sits down with Shawn O'Donnell, a professional player from Cole Harbour currently playing overseas in Germany, for a deep conversation on player development.They tackle a powerful question:If you could only choose one, would you develop a player with a professional coach or a professional player?Shawn shares insights from his 15+ year pro career, including time in the AHL, and explains why many elite players struggle to teach mechanics and fundamentals, despite incredible experience and hockey IQ. Kevin breaks down why structure, curriculum, progressions, and mechanical cues are essential for real development, and how Train 2.0 bridges the gap between what the NHL’s best do and what’s traditionally taught.From analyzing the top 1% like Connor McDavid, Sidney Crosby, and Nathan MacKinnon, to why mechanics-first learning accelerates improvement, this episode dives deep into what actually moves players forward.If you’re a player, parent, or coach looking to understand **how elite biomechanics are taught (not guessed) this episode is a must-listen.

People in this episode

Guest: Shawn O'Donnell

Topics covered

  • player development
  • coaching
  • professional players
  • hockey mechanics
  • elite biomechanics

Keywords

  • NHL
  • Connor McDavid
  • Sidney Crosby
  • Nathan MacKinnon
  • AHL

Mentioned in this episode

Products: Train 2.0

Books & works: The Train 2.0 Show

Places: Cole Harbour, Germany

More episodes of Train 2.0 Show with Jason Yee

Explore listener stats, chart rankings, contacts and more on the Train 2.0 Show with Jason Yee podcast page.