From Underground Pizza to Local Staple | The Benny’s Pizza Story w/ Ben Arona | Up+Adam

About this episode

Adam Montiel interviews Ben Arona about the journey of building Benny’s Pizza from an underground operation to a local staple.

Sponsored by The Mountain Air In Part 1 of this conversation, Adam sits down with Ben Arona, the mind behind Benny’s Pizza Palace & Social Club , and gets into the version of the story most people never see. Before the packed patio, before the social club energy, before it became a go-to spot in San Luis Obispo, this was one guy making dough in the morning, selling pizzas through Facebook, and trying to figure out if the whole thing would even work. They talk about the underground days, building a business out of a former chain pizza space, and what it actually looks like to scale something from nothing. There is a raw honesty here about the grind. Early mornings, long days, doing everything yourself, and slowly building systems that can hold the weight of growth. Ben breaks down how he went from making a couple pizzas at a time to running a full operation, and why structure and process became just as important as the product itself. Why Detroit style pizza? How he developed the sauce over years without changing it once it clicked. There is a moment in this episode where the conversation shifts from passion to pressure. Break-ins, unexpected costs, and the real numbers behind…

People in this episode

Host: Adam Montiel

Guest: Ben Arona

Topics covered

• entrepreneurship
• restaurant business
• pizza
• local business
• scaling
• challenges of entrepreneurship

Keywords

• Benny’s Pizza
• Ben Arona
• entrepreneurship
• restaurant challenges
• Detroit style pizza
• business growth
• San Luis Obispo

Sponsors

The Mountain Air

Mentioned in this episode

Organizations: Benny’s Pizza Palace & Social Club

Products: Detroit style pizza

Places: San Luis Obispo

More episodes of Up + Adam with Adam Montiel

• The People Behind Your Plate Are Closer Than You Think | Up+Adam · June 12, 2026 · 52 min
• Mayor Erica A. Stewart: State of SLO Is Stronger, But the Work Isn't Done | Up+Adam · June 11, 2026 · 56 min
• CITIZEN The Artist & Grace Bennett on Fame, Creativity, Relationships & Going Viral Again | Part 2 Up+Adam · June 10, 2026 · 41 min
• CITIZEN The Artist: Rare Interview with Phineas Peters & Grace Bennett - Building a Viral Independent Music Empire (From SLO) | Up+Adam · June 9, 2026 · 36 min
• Jimmy Paulding, SLO Supervisor is Up+Adam · June 2, 2026 · 50 min
• Slo County Supervisor Race | Michael Erin Woody on Public Trust & SLO CAL Issues | Up+Adam · May 27, 2026 · 1h 10m