Marketing Through Storytelling with Lance and Elaine Stitcher

About this episode

Lance and Elaine Stitcher discuss their award-winning marketing campaign that emphasizes community storytelling over traditional marketing methods.

In this episode of the VRMA Arrival podcast, Lance and Elaine Stitcher of Seaside Vacation & Sales share the story behind their 2025 VRMA Excellence Awards win for Best Marketing Campaign, and why the campaign was never really about Seaside at all. Celebrating both their company’s 10th anniversary and the 100th annual Chincoteague Pony Swim, the Seaside team challenged themselves to do something bold: create an original, feature-length documentary that honored the island’s history, culture, and people. Led by a small but highly creative in-house marketing team, the project became the centerpiece of a year-long storytelling campaign that extended far beyond the film itself, generating millions of social impressions, significant follower growth, and hundreds of thousands of dollars in directly attributable bookings. Lance and Elaine unpack how the campaign came together, how they measured success, and why community-first storytelling consistently outperforms traditional “listing-first” marketing. They also share practical takeaways for property managers of any size—whether or not they have a milestone event or a big budget—including how to repurpose content, spotlight local…

People in this episode

Guests: Elaine Stitcher, Lance Stitcher

Topics covered

• marketing
• storytelling
• community engagement
• vacation rentals

Keywords

• VRMA Excellence Awards
• Best Marketing Campaign
• Seaside Vacation & Sales
• Chincoteague Pony Swim
• documentary

Mentioned in this episode

Products: feature-length documentary

Books & works: Marketing Through Storytelling, VRMA Arrival, VRMA Excellence Awards, Best Marketing Campaign

Places: Seaside

More episodes of VRMA Arrival

• Short Term Rentalz’s Priya Khaira on the 2026 Shortyz Awards · March 30, 2026 · 11 min
• Pierre-Camille Hamana on Stacked Pressures, Operational Discipline, and the Future of STRs · February 23, 2026 · 19 min
• Salty Dog Vacations: Building a Business Around Community Impact · December 15, 2025 · 30 min
• Cautious Optimism: Key Data’s Read on the 2026 Vacation Rental Market · November 24, 2025 · 17 min
• Jessica Gillingham Talks AI, Hybrid Hospitality, and What Comes Next · September 29, 2025 · 25 min
• The Power of Membership: Education, Advocacy, and Connection with VRMA · July 28, 2025 · 14 min