When Systems Protect Abusers, Shame Steps In

When Systems Protect Abusers, Shame Steps In

From Heretic Hereafter Podcast by Katharine Strange

February 11, 2026 · 5 min · Season 3 · Episode 8

About this episode

The episode explores the relationship between shame and accountability in the context of social justice protests against ICE.

One of the many things that has struck me in recent weeks is the instances of Minneapolis protestors chanting, “Shame!” at ICE agents. It’s notable because many of these protestors are presumably Brené Brown-loving liberals who are, generally, not fans of shame. Where does this impulse come from? I’ve been chewing on the comments left by my amazing readers on last week’s post , and they’ve helped me realize that this impulse towards shame points to a broken system. One thing that a few deft readers pointed out is the difference between shame and accountability. Reader Stephanie Alter Jones put it this way: “…a lot of shamelessness among the powerful makes it seem like they "need" to be brought down in that way since they refuse to do it on their own. But rules-based social orders work better as accountability mechanisms for community behavior. I'd rather see rules or guidelines strengthened and followed rather than more public flogging.” And reader Christina added: “I do think consequences are more important than shame. I would much rather some of our shameless leaders be removed from power than for them to feel shame. Again, accountability but at the political rather than the…

People in this episode

Host: Katharine Strange

Topics covered

  • shame
  • accountability
  • protests
  • social justice
  • political systems

Keywords

  • shame
  • accountability
  • protests
  • social systems
  • political leaders

Mentioned in this episode

Organizations: ICE

Places: Minneapolis

More episodes of Heretic Hereafter Podcast

Explore listener stats, chart rankings, contacts and more on the Heretic Hereafter Podcast podcast page.