79. The Scientist and the Miracle

79. The Scientist and the Miracle

From Sideways by BBC Radio 4

February 11, 2026 · 29 min

About this episode

The episode explores the intersection of miracles and scientific thinking through the story of Joshua Brown, a neuroscience professor who sought a miracle after a devastating diagnosis.

Joshua Brown, a respected neuroscience professor at Indiana University was diagnosed with an inoperable brain tumour in 2003. It was devastating news, Joshua was only 30, and a new father. And so, with nothing to lose, he and his wife pursued an unconventional path - especially for a scientist. Together with their newborn daughter, they travelled across America, praying for a miracle. Matthew Syed delves into instances where inexplicable recoveries have been interpreted as evidence of divine intervention. He examines the unexpected ways in which the Vatican works with scientists to deem certain events miraculous. The whole idea touches on something deeply personal to Matthew as someone who grew up in a family that believed in miracle healings. He now struggles with the idea and is a firm non-believer, but he reunites with a much-loved pastor from his childhood for a frank conversation and meeting of their two viewpoints. Through Joshua’s remarkable journey, Matthew probes at whether miracles can ever be compatible with scientific thinking. With Joshua Brown, Professor of psychological and brain sciences at Indiana University and Director of the Global Medical Research Institute…

People in this episode

Host: Matthew Syed

Guests: Joshua Brown, Dr Ranjana Srivastava, Jacqueline Duffin, Nigel Thompson

Topics covered

  • neuroscience
  • miracles
  • faith and science
  • personal journey
  • medical recovery
  • divine intervention

Keywords

  • brain tumour
  • miracle healing
  • scientific thinking
  • Vatican
  • personal belief
  • neuroscience
  • recovery

Mentioned in this episode

Organizations: Indiana University, Global Medical Research Institute, Queen’s University, Canada, BBC Radio 4

More episodes of Sideways

Explore listener stats, chart rankings, contacts and more on the Sideways podcast page.